Did VP Biden Say Americans Would Have To ‘Buy In’ To His Healthcare Plan? | The 11th Hour | MSNBC


PAGE FOR AMERICA AND NOW PRESIDENT TRUMP, YOU CAN GO BACK PRESIDENT TRUMP, YOU CAN GO BACK TO WATCHING FOX NEWS. TO WATCHING FOX NEWS.>>AT THE CENTER OF THE STAGE>>AT THE CENTER OF THE STAGE TONIGHT, THE FRONT RUNNER AND TONIGHT, THE FRONT RUNNER AND THE BIGGEST TARGET OF THE THE BIGGEST TARGET OF THE EVENING, JOE BIDEN. EVENING, JOE BIDEN. AT ONE POINT JULIAN CASTRO AT ONE POINT JULIAN CASTRO APPEARED TO TAKE A SWIPE AT APPEARED TO TAKE A SWIPE AT BIDEN OVER WHAT HE SEEMED TO BIDEN OVER WHAT HE SEEMED TO REGARD AS SOME SORT OF SENIOR REGARD AS SOME SORT OF SENIOR MOMENT. MOMENT.>>THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHAT I>>THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHAT I SUPPORT AND WHAT YOU SUPPORT, SUPPORT AND WHAT YOU SUPPORT, VICE PRESIDENT BIDEN IS THAT YOU VICE PRESIDENT BIDEN IS THAT YOU REQUIRE THEM TO OPT IN, AND I REQUIRE THEM TO OPT IN, AND I WOULD NOT REQUIRE THEM TO OPT WOULD NOT REQUIRE THEM TO OPT IN. IN. THEY WOULD AUTOMATICALLY BE THEY WOULD AUTOMATICALLY BE ENROLLED. ENROLLED. THEY WOULDN’T HAVE TO BUY IN. THEY WOULDN’T HAVE TO BUY IN. THAT’S A BIG DIFFERENCE BECAUSE THAT’S A BIG DIFFERENCE BECAUSE BARACK OBAMA’S VISION WAS NOT TO BARACK OBAMA’S VISION WAS NOT TO LEAVE 10 MILLION PEOPLE LEAVE 10 MILLION PEOPLE UNCOVERED. UNCOVERED. HE WANTED EVERY SINGLE PERSON IN HE WANTED EVERY SINGLE PERSON IN THIS COUNTRY COVERED. THIS COUNTRY COVERED. MY PLAN WOULD DO THAT. MY PLAN WOULD DO THAT. YOUR PLAN WOULD NOT. YOUR PLAN WOULD NOT.>>THEY DO NOT HAVE TO BUY IN.>>THEY DO NOT HAVE TO BUY IN. THEY DO NOT HAVE TO BUY IN. THEY DO NOT HAVE TO BUY IN.>>YOU JUST SAID THAT.>>YOU JUST SAID THAT. YOU JUST SAID THAT TWO MINUTES YOU JUST SAID THAT TWO MINUTES AGO. AGO. YOU JUST SAID TWO MINUTES AGO YOU JUST SAID TWO MINUTES AGO THAT THEY WOULD HAVE TO BUY IN. THAT THEY WOULD HAVE TO BUY IN. YOU SAID THEY WOULD HAVE TO BUY YOU SAID THEY WOULD HAVE TO BUY IN. IN.>>IF YOU QUALIFY FOR>>IF YOU QUALIFY FOR MEDICAID — MEDICAID –>>ARE YOU FORGETTING WHAT YOU>>ARE YOU FORGETTING WHAT YOU SAID TWO MINUTES AGO? SAID TWO MINUTES AGO? ARE YOU FORGETTING ALREADY WHAT ARE YOU FORGETTING ALREADY WHAT YOU SAID JUST TWO MINUTES AGO? YOU SAID JUST TWO MINUTES AGO? I MEAN, I CAN’T BELIEVE THAT YOU I MEAN, I CAN’T BELIEVE THAT YOU SAID TWO MINUTES AGO THAT THEY SAID TWO MINUTES AGO THAT THEY HAD TO BUY IN AND NOW YOU’RE HAD TO BUY IN AND NOW YOU’RE SAYING THEY DON’T HAVE TO BUY. SAYING THEY DON’T HAVE TO BUY. YOU’RE FORGETTING THAT, I MEAN, YOU’RE FORGETTING THAT, I MEAN, LOOK. LOOK.>>ANY GRANDMOTHER WHO HAS NO>>ANY GRANDMOTHER WHO HAS NO MONEY — MONEY –>>WE NEED A HEALTH CARE>>WE NEED A HEALTH CARE SYSTEM — SYSTEM –>>YOU’RE AUTOMATICALLY>>YOU’RE AUTOMATICALLY ENROLLED. ENROLLED.>>YOU HEARD THE CROWD REACT IN>>YOU HEARD THE CROWD REACT IN REALTIME, CONTROVERSIAL MOMENT REALTIME, CONTROVERSIAL MOMENT FOR SURE. FOR SURE. IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO FIND IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO FIND OUT WHAT SANDERS SAID TO BIDEN OUT WHAT SANDERS SAID TO BIDEN THERE BETWEEN THE TWO MENTAL, THERE BETWEEN THE TWO MENTAL, BUT BUT T — MEN, THE ACCUSATION FROM T — MEN, THE ACCUSATION FROM CASTRO CALLS FOR A FACT CHECK. CASTRO CALLS FOR A FACT CHECK. IT APPEARS BIDEN DID NOT SAY IT APPEARS BIDEN DID NOT SAY AMERICANS WOULD HAVE TO BUY IN AMERICANS WOULD HAVE TO BUY IN TO HIS HEALTH CARE POLICY. TO HIS HEALTH CARE POLICY. HERE’S WHAT HE DID SAY. HERE’S WHAT HE DID SAY.>>MY HEALTH CARE PLAN DOES>>MY HEALTH CARE PLAN DOES SIGNIFICANTLY CUT THE COST OF SIGNIFICANTLY CUT THE COST OF THE LARGEST OUT-OF-POCKET THE LARGEST OUT-OF-POCKET PAYMENT YOU’LL PAY IS A THOUSAND PAYMENT YOU’LL PAY IS A THOUSAND DOLLARS. DOLLARS. YOU’LL BE ABLE TO GET TO GET INT YOU’LL BE ABLE TO GET TO GET INT ANYONE WHO CAN’T AFFORD IT GETS ANYONE WHO CAN’T AFFORD IT GETS AUTOMATICALLY ENROLLED. AUTOMATICALLY ENROLLED. GUESS WHAT. GUESS WHAT. OF 160 MILLION PEOPLE WHO LIKE

73 thoughts on “Did VP Biden Say Americans Would Have To ‘Buy In’ To His Healthcare Plan? | The 11th Hour | MSNBC

  • Well first of all of you don't like your health care,you can't just leave. You can't leave it you have no where to go. We need universal healthcare. Eliminate private insurance because they abused the system and can't be trusted.

  • 🎶BETH WE HEAR YOU'RE RUNNIN , WE JUST STOPPED TO TELL YOU "HOW" ME AND THE TROLLS ARE LAUGHING AND WE JUST CAN'T QUIT RIGHT NOW ! JUST A FEW MORE POW WOWS IT'LL BE THE END OF YOU ! CAN YOU HEAR US LAUGH'N ? OH BETH WHAT CAN WE DO ? BETH WE LAUGH AT YOU ! 🎵

  • This is inaccurate. Biden did say the words, “automatically buy-in” in separate comments from the clip that this video depicts.

  • Oborg of the CIA collective had 8 yrs to fix the USA .. 8 yrs and MSNBCannibals cheerlead for the same ilk of proven failures

  • Nice disingenuous fact-check MSNBC! How about you show the relevant clip where Biden absolutely does say “buy in?” Pathetic reporting.

  • Yes Americans it's shocking ! For a universal health Care system to work ALL PEOPLE Need to buy into it & be covered by it
    This is a common sense realization that over 3 quarters of the world had the intelegece to realise decades ago ( we are just to stupid for democracy)

  • Brian Williams did a partial fact checking.

    Yes Biden did say what Castro said he said. Biden asks the moderator for a 15 second interruption, out of turn, at the end of the Kamala Harris answer and Biden, not very clearly says the following verbatim, "Look everybody says you want an option, the option I'm proposing is a Medicare for all, uh eh, a Medicare for Choice, if you want Medicare, if you lose the job from your insurance comp, ah your employer, you automatically can buy into this, you don't have no precondition can stop you from buying in you get covered period."

    Biden went on to say, "And if you notice nobodies yet said how much this is going to cost the tax payer, I hear this large saving, the president thinks (pointing at Bernie Sanders thinking Bernie is the president), oh ah my friend from Vermont thinks that your employer is going to give that money back if you [etc. etc. etc.]"

    A short time later (2 minutes) Castro is identifying his health plan and pointing out the opt in, opt out difference between his plan and the Biden plan. Castro reiterates what Biden had just stated to Bernie during Biden's requested 15 second interruption. Biden then denies the "buy in" thing and starts to rant something about someone's grandmother. I tuned out then.

    There you go. Fact checked. Watch the video.

  • Warren/Bernie 2020. Time for real change, not centrist/moderate/corporate/repub light "dems" like biden.

    That kind of status quo is part of the reason 45* was installed: many dems are sick of dems being almost as plutocrat as repubs and so didn't vote for HRC (especially after the failed promise of obama, another corporate shill).

  • Republicans often claim Democrats are weak, yet when a Democrat (in this case Castro) actually talks tough and ruffles feathers of the Washington elite, he is called out as hurting his own message. I for one want a President who has good, progressive policy and is willing to buck the system/establishment to get things done. And, while Castro isn't the most progressive, he certainly has been outlining specific policies and calling out corporate/establishment Democrats from all 3 Debates.

  • "If you want medicare if you lose the job from your insurance company (gaffe), from your employer, you automatically can buy into this" Biden said.

  • To some, $1000 may as well be $100,000. But guess what. I don't have US private insurance- you might, lucky you, I don't know you at all.
    Biden double talk used car salesman's pitch.
    He still makes my skin crawl.

  • Are you even journalists anymore? He did say “if you lose the job from….your employer, you automatically can buy in to this”…..outright dishonest liars….this is why people call you fake news

  • The usual Dem infighting, so disappointing. If it carries on we are going to have a mentally ill person in the white house for another 4 years. Dem's, please come together, talk about the issues that matter and stop Trump bashing.

  • Julián Castro screwed up!
    But Joe Biden IS UNELECTABLE!

    It's not JUST about the 1994 Crime Bill – it's that the argument Trump and the Russians put forth against Hillary Clinton back then and Joe Biden now WAS THE TRUTH!

    Bill Clinton and Joe Biden ARE responsible for the US mass incarceration AND the prisoner slave labor issue AND the unbelievable growth of private prisons! … and MOST OF THE VICTIMS OF OF THAT POLICY WERE BLACK MEN!

    Joe Biden is unelectable and will lose to Trump!

    Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren or God Knows ANY DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATE BESIDES JOE F**KING BIDEN!!!! in 2020.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6EZygf-nqpU

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8TkDorYCIc&t=150s

  • JULIAN CASTRO GAINED OUR SUPPORT LAST NIGHT.
    JOE BIDEN HATES BROWN PEOPLE AND SO DOES BRIAN WILLIAMS AND KCDC2 NEXT TO HIM.

  • I just hope they thin the herd down before the start of 2020. It's all about marketing your favorite B.S., to us dumbed down peasants. Still none of this matters, it is just selling TV time so everyone else can make more money! But it is funny how all the russian trolls, 1% corporate slugs and ignorant Americans are out here attacking the democrats candidate, any which could be real contender against the 1%'s puppet in the White House. Remember all the attack against Nancy Pelosi, another threat against these traitorous criminals that have conned their way into power. You forget the old 1% propaganda, "why bother to vote" , "your vote doesn't matter!" So I guess you're still waiting for that trickle down, still believing in the soulless 1%. Sadly with the 1% controlled senate, the POS orange orangutan criminal is still needed to divide and dismantle our nation, returning it to their 1% lords & masters. But at least with Impeachment, the Democrats can exposes which traitorous republicans in the senate, have sold their souls; and have The Blood of Our Constitution on their hands. As the senate will never betray their oath to the 1% donors, and convict. So I still think that the really smart brain, traitor drumpf will start a war, declares Martial Law, and ends elections. Then you will not have to worry about self-rule anymore; the 1% donor controlled senate will back the puppet! So get your favorite Corporate Flags out, it's only going to cost millions of your children! Just close your eyes and return to your Reality TV, FakeBook and your Flat Earth. Watch as drumpf's biggest distraction is to come. MAKE AMERICA WHITE AGAIN, I mean Great. The only question left now is, will you bow down and take their mark?

  • The attacks on Julian by MSM are worst than anything that happened on stage. Hope Nicole and McCaskill apologize for putting words in Julian's mouth. They need to stop coddling Biden. I dislike him more every day. Great VP, horribly embarrassing presidential candidate. So incoherent, blabbering on, throws Obama under bus on imigration. Julian defended his performance where was Joe? KEEP FIGHTING FOR THE PEOPLE JULIAN! Keep calling out establishment lies! We see you!

  • Yes, Biden did say that. I heard it loud and clear and agreed 100% with Castro's response. He was mirroring my feelings exactly. Joe's a mess.

  • You didn't include the clip where he DID say you can buy into the plan. I heard it loud and clear and it got my attention. Why is everyone babying and protecting Biden? It's nuts. Like when Reagan didn't know what the heck was going on – dementia. God, what is wrong with you guys. Play the entire clip of what he said!

  • That was disgusting . Joe Biden definitely did say that " You can buy in ".   We all know that public speakers sometimes stumble over themselves . However , when that happens you need to clarify  or rephrase your comments.  However , part of being a good leader is the ability to make yourself understood . If you are often getting misunderstood , because of your inability to articulate yourself very well ,  voters have a right to wonder about your suitability for a job that requires making yourself understood .         ( Why did  Brian Williams get this so wrong ?  )

  • He going to regret attacked Vice President Joe Biden and the sad part the young man would never win and he would never become president

  • MSNBC stop gaslighting us. It’s clear as day in the debate at 31:08 that he said you can “buy in.” I heard it when I first watched the debate, and I just confirmed it now.

  • This is a quote from Biden at the debate:

    “If you want Medicare, if you lose the job from your insurance company, from your employer, you automatically can buy into this,” Mr. Biden said earlier. “You don’t have — no pre-existing condition can stop you from buying in. You get covered. Period.”

    Note “buy in”

  • 'Anyone who can afford it get's automatically enrolled' Yes, that is a buy-in construction. And before this he had already mentioned you could buy in to his plan. I did not like Castro's attack but he was right. Why are you purposely misleading your viewers MSNBC?

  • What memory? Joe's slogan vote for Joe. What happens in kindergarten stays in kindergarten. Is that a recording device? Pull your pampers back up!

  • From what I could tell what Biden said was the moment you don't have private insurance you will "automatically buy-in", Castro really embarrassed himself here but because Biden has been making a lot of mistakes lately and he used the words "buy-in" it also confused the audience enough that it became a two-edged sword and basically ended up hurting both of them.
    Kind of like Castro just pulled the pin out of a hand-grenade and threw himself on Biden just on the hint that he might be an enemy and now everyone's just confused.

  • I said if they lose their job they had to buy in. I never said they had to buy in. MSNBC is 100% correct I never said they had to buy in, I only said they had to buy in, which I never said.

  • The "buy in" comment was edited out. Start watching at 30:50 to hear the "buy in" statement. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2UWVO0Trd1c

  • Castro was right to call him out on this, although he should have refrained from the "did you forget" comment. I heard it too. Biden said those who don't have employer healthcare can "buy in" to his program. This guy (Biden) is so out of touch with America. You're unemployed, you're looking for a job, it's been 6 months, oh yeah, let me just "buy in" to this crap healthcare and waste $200 a month instead of saving that money for rent, groceries, utilities.

  • Here you go. At 4:00 Trevor Noah plays the clip where Joe absolutely does say you have to buy into his healthcare plan. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2heqqCYCR2s You need to apologize for this mistake Brian Williams.

  • Thats a lie Corporate media helping Joe Biden. He did say you would have to buy in. I link actual video proof.

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/julian-castro-questioned-joe-bidens-acuity-but-did-castro-get-it-right/2019/09/13/46359a6c-d576-11e9-9343-40db57cf6abd_story.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *